It doesn't take much to realize that banning saggy pants is kind of ridiculous unless, of course, you believe that will make some kind of difference in regards to the bad things in the world:
Last week, Atlanta Councilman C. T. Martin sponsored an amendment to the city's indecency laws to ban sagging, which he called an epidemic. "We are trying to craft a remedy," said Mr. Martin, who sees the problem as "a prison mentality."
Well, there you go, prisoners go home and launch the saggy style, saggy styles get picked up by forward fashion youth, the saggy style then spreads everywhere, therefore, kids have a prison mentality. Ask around and see if any kids wearing saggy clothes would describe themselves as dressing like prisoners.
Things start one place and change as they spread. If you want to make a direct connection back to the beginning, you've got to provide some evidence, not a leap of logic that looks more like a leap of faith.
Niko Koppel does a nice job overall with this look at the variety of places banning saggy pants and the various issues involved. Unfortunately, I can't buy this line which is a big one if accepted at face value:
Not since the zoot suit has a style been greeted with such strong disapproval.
Between the zoot suit and now, lots of people have gotten seriously injured for dressing in disapproved ways. Ask the hippies. That's not to say that one couldn't draw many parallels but we haven't seen anything like the Zoot Suit Riots in relationship to saggy pants.
Apparently HSAN may get involved:
Benjamin Chavis, the former executive director of the N.A.A.C.P., said, “I think to criminalize how a person wears their clothing is more offensive than what the remedy is trying to do.”
Dr. Chavis, who is often pictured in an impeccable suit and tie among the baggy outfits of the hip-hop elite, is a chairman of the Hip Hop Summit Action Network, a coalition he founded with the music mogul Russell Simmons. He said that the coalition will challenge the ordinances in court.
“The focus should be on cleaning up the social conditions that the sagging pants comes out of,” he said. “That they wear their pants the way they do is a statement of the reality that they’re struggling with on a day-to-day basis.”
HSAN would be an appropriate group to take this on though I'll be surprised if they do anything substantial with this issue in terms of legal action. And the idea that all these saggy pants wearing people are reflecting their struggle in their clothing is also kind of ridiculous but I guess we'll be encountering that soundbite over and over in press releases and media coverage as soon as HSAN starts holding press conferences on the matter.
There are very serious issues at stake here in terms of self-expression and freedom of speech but also in terms of potential harassment of saggy pants wearing people. I don't believe these initiatives will successfully make it through the courts but I do know that as soon as they pass locally, cops won't be swarming the malls, they'll be swarming low-income neighborhoods and clearing the streets.
Now if you'd promise me showcase raids on malls filled with rich white kids, heck, rich kids of any color, then I might sign on just for entertainment.
Recent Comments